Lesson 9 · 18 min

Minor scales and minor keys

The relative minor, the natural, harmonic and melodic minor scales, and how to tell a minor key from its major.

Open this lesson in dacapo

In the app the figures sound and answer to your keyboard, and the exercises check what you play.

Every scale so far has been major. Its partner is the minor, darker and sadder, and many of the pieces you will play are in a minor key. Each minor key shares its notes with a major key, but has a home of its own, and its scale comes in three forms.

The sound of minor

Play a tune you know twice, once in major and once in minor. Only one note changes: the third note of the scale, E in C major, is a half step lower in C minor, E♭. That one key turns a bright tune dark.

Plate Listen in C major, then switch to C minor and listen again. Only E changes.

What you hear is the distance from the tonic, the scale’s first note, to its third. In major it is four half steps, a major third; in minor it is three, a minor third. Stack the tonic, the third and the fifth note into a chord, and it is major or minor for the same reason: C E G sounds bright, C E♭ G sad.

C → E♭Three half steps: a minor third

Plate Switch between major and minor, and listen to the third and to the chord.

The relative minor

Play the white keys again, but from A to A: A B C D E F G A. They are the same seven notes as C major, and yet the scale sounds minor, because A is now home. This is A minor, the relative minor of C major.

Every major key has a relative minor. It starts on the major scale’s 6th note or, counting down, a minor third below its tonic: C, B, A. The two share every note, and so they share the key signature.

A minor starts on the 6th note of C major.

12345678
Plate Choose a major key and listen to its scale, then switch to its relative minor. The notes and the key signature stay; only the first note moves.

The natural minor

The notes from A to A with nothing changed are the natural minor scale. Measure its steps as you did for the major: whole, half, whole, whole, half, whole, whole. The half steps fall in other places, between the 2nd and 3rd notes and between the 5th and 6th, and that is what makes it minor.

Start on any key and follow the pattern, and you get that key’s natural minor. From E it needs F♯, from D it needs B♭: the sharps and flats of G major and F major, their relative majors.

  1. AW
  2. BH
  3. CW
  4. DW
  5. EH
  6. FW
  7. GW
  8. A
Plate Choose a key and a minor: the row shows the steps, the keyboard the scale. Notes raised from the natural minor are coloured. With Key signature, only what the signature does not give is written.

The harmonic minor

Play A natural minor to the top and listen to its last step, G to A. It is a whole step, and the scale drifts home rather than arriving. Raise the 7th note a half step, to G♯, and the last step is a half step: G♯ leans into A the way B leans into C in C major. A 7th a half step below the tonic is called the leading note, because it leads there.

The natural minor with its 7th raised is the harmonic minor. It is named after harmony: at the end of a piece in A minor, the chord on E before the last chord needs G♯ to sound final. Most minor pieces raise the 7th like this, so expect to see it.

G♯ → AA half step: a leading note. F → G♯ is a step and a half.

Plate Switch between G and G♯, and listen to the top of the scale and to the two chords that end a piece in A minor.

Raising the 7th leaves a wide gap below it: F to G♯ is three half steps, a step and a half. You hear it as a small leap in the scale. Choose Harmonic in the scale above to see the whole pattern: whole, half, whole, whole, half, step and a half, half.

The melodic minor

A step and a half is awkward to sing, so a tune climbing to the tonic often raises the 6th as well: F♯ and G♯ in A minor. Going up, the melodic minor is whole, half, whole, whole, whole, whole, half. It differs from A major only in its third note.

Coming down there is no leading note to satisfy, so both go back: G, then F. The melodic minor comes down as the natural minor, and that is how the Scales page plays it.

  1. AW
  2. BH
  3. CW
  4. DW
  5. EW
  6. F♯W
  7. G♯H
  8. A
  1. AW
  2. GW
  3. FH
  4. EW
  5. DW
  6. CH
  7. BW
  8. A
Plate The melodic minor goes up with its 6th and 7th raised and comes down natural. Try another key: in D minor, B♭ becomes B and C becomes C♯ on the way up.

Minor key signatures

A minor key uses its relative major’s key signature. A minor has none, like C major; E minor has one sharp, like G major; D minor one flat, like F major. The raised 6th and 7th are never in the signature: they are written as accidentals where they occur.

So one signature fits two keys. To tell which one a piece is in, look at its end, and look for the raised 7th. A piece nearly always ends on its tonic, with the tonic in the bass: one that ends on A over A is in A minor, one that ends on C in C major. And a G♯ that keeps appearing, the raised 7th, says A minor; C major has no use for it.

It ends on A, over A in the bass, after G♯: the raised 7th.

Plate Two phrases, neither with sharps or flats in the signature. Switch between them: the one in A minor ends on A, over A in the bass, with G♯ on the way.

C minor is not C major’s relative. It is its parallel minor: the minor key on the same tonic, with another signature, three flats, B♭ E♭ A♭. The tune at the top of this lesson went from C major to its parallel minor.

Try it

Find relative minors from their signatures, then play a harmonic minor scale, then tell the three minors apart and name the key of a few phrases.

This exercise is played in the app.

Play A harmonic minor with the right hand, up and back down, following the fingers marked on the keys. Going up, the thumb passes under after the third finger, onto D.

This exercise is played in the app.

This exercise is played in the app.

This exercise is played in the app.

On the Scales page every minor key waits in all three forms, one to four octaves, both hands, with Hanon’s fingering for the harmonic and melodic minors.